Why I Gave Up on Buying a Rental Property in 2018

Why I Gave Up on Buying a Rental Property in 2018My husband and I made very few new investments this year.

And there’s a perfectly solid reason for that: we have been saving for the down payment on our first rental property, so we needed to keep our money liquid.

Rental properties can produce handsome returns if you get great deals in the right market. 

Here are just some of the ways investing in rental properties could benefit you:

  • Potential capital appreciation
  • Monthly cash flow
  • The loan is paid down by renters
  • Financial leverage
  • Demand for rental properties is likely to grow as qualifying for a mortgage becomes more difficult
  • Multiple paths to profit
  • Tax benefits

Our goal is to buy 1 or 2 rental properties within 3 years, and we’re dead serious about making it happen.

Since November 2017, we have been semi-actively hunting for rental properties and began the process of talking to realtors and looking at mortgage options.

We’re pretty new at this, so we’re treading exceedingly carefully.

Because we’re choosing to employ the buy and hold strategy (i.e., buying properties and holding on to them for decades), we want to ensure that the units we end up buying have long-term growth potential and can cash flow right away.

So with that in mind, we set out to look for affordable rental properties that fit the bill.

Option #1:

Initially, we wanted to get something fairly close to where we live to manage it ourselves.

Mississauga apartment building

When I was a university student, I lived in a 5-bedroom condo with roommates who attended the same university. The rent was more than reasonable, and I never had any complaints about my living situation. The building was a 5-minute bus away from the university, so the vacancy rate was effectively 0%.

I thought this could potentially work. I know the area like the back of my hand, and I love the idea of renting to college students.

So I searched for new listings in that building and ran the numbers.

Alas, the sale prices more than doubled since the time I lived there (from low 200s to mid 400s), the maintenance fee shot up by 17%, but the rent only increased by 50%, making this a mediocre deal at best.

Sadly, I had to pass on that.

Option #2:

Then we decided to expand our area to the entire west side of GTA (Greater Toronto Area), including Hamilton.

Thanks to some serious urban revitalization efforts, Hamilton has, in recent years, taken on a new reputation as a hip place to live in.

Hamilton Ontario

You know what that means: a growing number of folks who fled Toronto because of rising housing prices have begun to establish roots in Hamilton.

Other real estate investors have been eyeing this part of Ontario too, so property deals are extremely tough to find.

We quickly decided that this market had already become too hot for us.

As we moved our search area farther and farther away from home, it finally dawned on us: perhaps we should look in Montreal.

Option #3:

My husband and I both lived in Montreal before, for a combined 12 years. So we’re intimately familiar with the city and its neighborhoods.


Being one of Canada’s hottest real estate markets in 2017, sales growth in Montreal has dwarfed that of Toronto and Vancouver for the first time in 20 years. A few factors were in play: low unemployment, economic growth, and the lack of foreign buyers tax.

The moderately high rental prices coupled with new infrastructure projects (such as the new Champlain Bridge and the light rail network) also make Montreal an attractive market in the eyes of savvy investors.

Of course, we’re not the only ones aware of that. In fact, it appears that we were unfashionably late to the party.

After viewing many properties in Montreal, including pre-construction units, we decided to bow out gracefully.

Soon after, we threw in the towel on the whole idea.

Here are the reasons we ultimately decided not to buy a rental property this year.

Reason #1: We can’t find a good deal

Finding a property that cash flows is akin to capturing a unicorn for us.

Once you consider the monthly costs of the loan payment, insurance, taxes, property management, maintenance, and repairs, most rental properties listed on the MLS don’t generate a positive cash flow.

Good deals DO exist, just not always in plain view. Although I feel shy about admitting it, finding great deals requires more time, expertise, and connections than we currently have.

Reason #2: We wouldn’t qualify for a sizable mortgage

The properties that we are most interested in – duplexes in certain parts of Montreal, for example – are currently out of our price range.

We can come up with the 25% down payment. The challenge lies in finding a lender that could lend us the rest at a reasonable rate.

Unfortunately, our current mortgage provider does not fund purchases in Quebec (to their credit, they did make a few helpful recommendations), and given the size of our existing home mortgage, it is unlikely that we can get additional funding anywhere else.

We have inquired with major banks and multiple mortgage brokers, and received some variation of “it would be challenging” in every case.

Reason #3: Opportunity cost

In early February, the Dow Jones industrial average fell 180.24 points due to a sharp rise in interest rates, followed by a 4-day winning streak.

Market swings like this happen once in a blue moon, but they can be a godsend to investors who want to acquire stocks at bargain prices.

I am actively tracking 50+ stocks, and receive a text message whenever a stock hits my target price. On the day that Dow Jones nosedived, I was bombarded with messages left and right, but couldn’t do anything about it: our cash savings are earmarked for the down payment of our rental property.

As long as we hold on to our cash in the hopes of finding a property, we will continue to miss out on other great investing opportunities. That opportunity cost is getting harder and harder to justify.

Reason #4: We want to renew our mortgage with a major bank

We like our mortgage lender for various reasons. Still, we hope to switch our mortgage provider to one of the Big Five later this year (for those who aren’t familiar with Canadian banks, Big Five is the moniker assigned to the 5 largest banks in Canada).

There are significant upsides of doing so, including:

  • Access to HELOC (home equity line of credit)
  • Lower mortgage rates
  • Ability to make extra monthly payments toward principal

On the flip side, bigger banks tend to have more stringent mortgage qualification requirements. If we want to secure a mortgage with them, we have to strengthen our finances.

We fear that borrowing more (thus increasing our debts) could jeopardize our chances of getting a mortgage with the Big Five, even if it is for purchasing a rental property that generates additional revenue for us.

Reason #5: Investing for the sake of investing is rarely a good idea

We would really like to add a rental property to our investment portfolio as soon as possible.

On some days, it’s all I can think and talk about.

But we can’t just say “yes” to the first property that we could afford, just to check the task off the list. I have to remain vigilant about not letting my desire to own a rental home trump rational decision-making. Great investment decisions are rarely made when emotions are at play.

What’s Next?

Now that we have decided not to buy a rental property this year, the money we have saved for the down payment is freed up. Here is what we plan to do with that money:

  1. Maximize this year’s RRSP contributions
  2. Put as much as we can into our TFSAs (we don’t have to worry about going over the limits yet)
  3. Invest in P2P lending 
  4. Paying our 2017 taxes

Of course, while our real estate journey is temporarily halted, it does not end here.

We figured that our best course of action going forward would be to partner with a joint venture (JV) partner — a common practice among experienced real estate investors.

In the best-case scenario, partnering up would enable us to pool money, connections, and skills together to achieve greater returns at a higher success rate.

That sounds great, doesn’t it?

But finding the right JV partner and negotiating a fair deal for all parties involved? That’s a whole other topic on its own.

Enjoyed this article? Connect with Casual Money Talk on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and Pinterest, and don't forget to sign up for our email newsletter to be notified of future content.

Category: InvestingLife Stories

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Article by: Flora Pang

Flora Pang aspires to become someone who plants trees in their spare time, writes thank-you notes to strangers, and serves in UN peacekeeping operations around the world. But to date, blogging about personal finance remains her only contribution to society. You can catch her rambling about money on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and (to a lesser extent) Pinterest.